Skip to content

Forum for the Future of Aid

Southern Voices for Change in the International Aid System Project

The Forum on the Future of Aid is an online community dedicated to research and opinions about how the international aid system currently works and where it should go next

organised by ODI

Reforming Aid Architecture – what role for the Commonwealth?

Commonwealth Finance Ministers held their annual meeting 12th-14th September 2006) on the theme of ‘Growth with or without new jobs?’ – Commonwealth Finance Ministers to re-examine the secrets of economic success’ . The timing was designed to fall just before the annual meetings of the World Bank and IMF which this year takes place in Singapore.

This year’s Finance Ministers’ meeting discussed a full agenda including the usual look at the current world economic situation, small states issues, private finance and investment issues, and this year’s theme of growth and livelihoods.

In addition, ministers considered a role for the Commonwealth in the growing international debate about the Aid Architecture. Ministers have been presented with five options for reform of the international architecture in a paper produced for the meeting. These options have been drawn from a series of workshops with Commonwealth finance ministry officials and civil society representatives which took place in London, UK, Dhaka, Bangladesh and Yaoundé, Cameroon. The five options presented were:

1. Option A – Do Nothing - Slow implementation of Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness; creation of more vertical funds and special purpose vehicles.
2. Option B - Rely on Harmonisation and Alignment - Gradual implementation of Paris Declaration leads to better H&A at country level; new vertical funds and special purpose vehicles continue to be created; DAC remains largely a bilateral donor club.
3. Option C – Harmonisation and Alignment+ - Recipient countries take the lead in driving H&A; donor numbers in each country controlled, with more joint programmes and offices; DAC should become open to wider membership, including non-OECD member observers; national level Paris Declaration agreements and 10-year partnership agreements agreed; mutual peer review programmes implemented; independent monitoring group at country level begins and countries request multi-donor evaluations; publication of a World Aid Report considered; the UN sets norms and standards for co-ordination, harmonisation and delivery of aid.
4. Option D - Multilateralism - A determined effort is made to simplify the aid system while retaining diversity, by increasing the share of aid channelled through the World Bank, the UN, the MDBs and the EU; UN and IFI governance reform is given high priority and a single UN Development fund formed; a forum such as a reformed and strengthened ECOSOC becomes the principal arena for discussion of aid issues.
5. Option E – Empower Recipient Governments - Developing countries are equipped with better information about the relative performance of aid agencies, the result of independent monitoring and evaluation; they are then given more say in the choice of which agencies act as suppliers of aid, perhaps through vouchers or similar; A forum such as a reformed and strengthened ECOSOC becomes the principal arena for discussion of aid issues.

In thinking about the reform of the international aid architecture and these different options, Ministers were asked to consider what role there might be for the Commonwealth given that it has both an interest in the issues and, given its unique membership and convening power, the capacity to help shape the debate.
At a minimum, the Commonwealth might content itself with monitoring progress against the Paris Declaration and providing assistance to countries which wish to strengthen their capacity to manage aid flows successfully. At a maximum, the Commonwealth could position itself in a position of leadership in the global action programme to reform aid architecture. This would obviously require both commitment and investment in a collective project.

1. Does the Commonwealth offer a unique perspective on these issues?
2. Is the Commonwealth able to play a distinctive role in the debate and help resolve differences and tensions present in other forums which discuss the issue?
3. What role should the Commonwealth play if the answer to those two questions is yes?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Role for Commonwealth
Submitted by rosanwo on Fri, 2006-11-03 12:25.

Within the developing countries, there are countries that are leaders and have influence over others i.e. Nigeria, South Africa, t belonging to the Commowealth.
If option E is adopted the recipient countries will have the capacity to deliver and this will position the Commonwealth as a global leader in the global action plan to reform aid architecture. It is paramount and of importance that the Commonwealth countries can debate at any level the position of the Commowealth in their regions and globally.
The Commowealth must be seen to be embracing the task ahead.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Log In or Join

Resource Categories

Size of tags indicates the number of resources
Absorption Accountability Africa Aid Architecture Aid Architecture Aid effectiveness Aid linkages Aid modalities Aid organisations All regions Asia Pacific Bilateral Donors Budget Support By Region Capacity Development Conditionality Corruption CSOs Debt Relief Domestic Resource Mobilisation Donor Coordination Mechanisms Economic Growth Education Effects of aid Emergencies Environment Europe Food Aid Gender Good Humanitarian Donorship Governance Harmonisation & Alignment Health Hot Topics Humanitarian Aid Quality Institutions Latest trends Latin America and Caribbean Macro impacts/Dutch Disease MDGs Middle East Multilateral and International (governmental) Organisations National Policy Frameworks/PRSs Natural Disasters NGOs Ownership Productive Sectors Public Expenditure Management/Budget Sector Programme based approaches Technical Assistance Trade Vertical Programmes/Global Initiatives Workshops

Recent Forum Posts

  • The Paris Declaration is Gender Blind
  • The urgent need for transparency and accountability
  • Your Support is needed in Egypt
  • Independent People's Tribunal on the World Bank Group
  • South and the future of the world

Suggest a Resource

If you would like to suggest a resource for the Forum on the Future of Aid, please email